BINI Faces Backlash Over Disturbing "Joke" About Violence Towards a Minor: Fans Demand Accountability

BINI, the fast-rising P-pop girl group known for promoting women empowerment and inspiring a new generation of young girls through their music and advocacy, is now under intense scrutiny after a controversial video surfaced online. In the video, three members—Stacey, Colet, and Jhoanna—are seen casually discussing what appears to be a disturbing incident involving physical violence toward a then-13-year-old girl, allegedly named Ashley or Ashtine.

The Viral Clip

In the short video clip circulating on social media and Reddit, Stacey is heard saying:

“Ganiyan ginagawa niya kay Ashtine/Ashley (?)… sinasabunutan.”

To which Colet replies:

“Oo. 13 years old.”

Jhoanna then reacts with apparent shock:

“Ahhh, 13 years old.”

While the conversation seems off-the-cuff, many found it deeply inappropriate, especially in light of BINI’s public image. The group recently hosted an event for their youngest fans—the Baby Blooms—emphasizing female empowerment and strength. To see members making light of violence toward a minor has left many fans disappointed and confused.

---

Fan Reactions: “Disappointing,” “Disturbing,” and “Out of Character”

Comments on Reddit and Twitter have been overwhelmingly negative:

• “Disappointing. Jusko. Hindi ko ineexpect silang 3 pa ang involved.”

• “Jhoanna, leader ka pa naman at sobrang vocal about your women empowerment advocacy.”

• “Stacey, unica hija ng isang single mother.”

• “Colet, matapang ka pero wala pala sa lugar ang katapangan.”

Some fans are also pointing out patterns in behavior:

• “Mabilis siyang pumatol. Pero pag siya yung mali, tahimik. Isama mo pa na mainitin ang ulo.”

• “Wala bang professionalism workshops na binigay ang management nila?”

---

Colet Under Fire

Particularly under the spotlight is Colet, who allegedly filmed the video and uploaded it. Netizens are now questioning her judgment and intent:

“Si Colet daw nagvivideo, siya din nagdump. Ano thought process ni ate gurl???? Siya pa yung nagbanggit ng 13 yrs old. Ang disturbing.”

Her mention of the girl’s age—13 years old—struck a nerve with many fans. For a group marketed as role models, and who actively position themselves as voices for the youth, joking about violence involving a minor was seen as a severe lapse in judgment.

---

No Official Statement… Yet

As of writing, there has been no official statement from BINI or their management, ABS-CBN / Star Magic / Star Hunt, leaving fans to speculate and voice their concerns online. Many believe this silence is damaging, especially as the video continues to spread.

---

“They’re Still Young”—But Is That an Excuse?

While some fans have urged others to be understanding, noting that the girls are still in their early 20s, many counter with:

“I know they’re young, but surely 21 is old enough not to make jokes like this, no?”

Another adds:

“Ang babata niyo pa. Gets naman na hindi perfect ang mga idols. Pero sana maingat naman kayo sa mga galaw niyo. Ang kalat.”

---

What Comes Next?

At this point, fans and onlookers are divided—some calling for accountability and proper media training, while others are simply heartbroken by what feels like a betrayal of the values BINI publicly stands for.

With such a strong platform and an impressionable fanbase, BINI members are expected to uphold the standards they advocate. Whether this incident results in a public apology, internal disciplinary actions, or fades into silence remains to be seen.